Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Most of the Researchers doubt now the validity and reliability of the IEEE

Most of the Researchers doubt now the validity and reliability of the IEEE


http://groups.google.com/group/alt.college.camp-all-stars/browse_thread/thread/01928db0bf204a85


References

1) http://crappyconference.blogspot.com


A letter from Evan M. Butterfield (Director of Products & Services, IEEE Computer Society10662 Los Vaqueros Circle, Los Alamitos, CA 90720714.816.2165) informed in Jan 17, 2009 the following:

This is the official confession of IEEE Fake Conferences (Many Sites on the Web have Published it)


From: EButterfield@computer.org
to: EButterfield@computer.org
cc: ABurgess@computer.org,
John Walz: ,
"Reisman, Sorel" , AStickley@computer.org, TBaldwin@computer.org, r.sterritt@ulster.ac.uk

date Sat, Jan 17, 2009 at 4:03 AMsubject Confidential: Important CPS Message Regarding Fraudulent Machine-Generated Paper Submissions


TO: CPS Clients FROM: Evan Butterfield, Director of Products and Services RE: Fraudulent Machine-Generated Paper Submissions (CONFIDENTIAL) DATE: 16 January 2009

 
The IEEE Computer Society (CS) has evidence that multiple (IEEE) conferences are receiving machine-generated papers. In two cases, conferences have actually accepted an obviously fraudulent submission. This is a serious issue that threatens the credibility of your conference, the quality of the digital library, and the reputation of both the IEEE and CS. It requires your immediate attention. Please take this opportunity to ensure that your peer review processes are being followed, and adapt to any new requirements that may be communicated by the IEEE or the Computer Society. No conference published by CPS should rely on an abstract review. It is very important that you review carefully the full text of all papers submitted to your conference. If you have already accepted papers, your program committee should review the full text again. While CPS staff will be conducting random spot-checks of conference papers in the publishing queue, we are relying on you to authenticate the content of your proceedings. Any papers that were not actually presented at your conference need to be brought to our attention, and should receive close review. In known cases, the machine-generated origin is obvious from a reading of the first few paragraphs of the paper; the abstracts are human-generated and do not indicate the quality of the paper itself. In the past, papers have been submitted by “Herbert Schlangemann,” but be mindful that the perpetrator of this fraud will change the approach over time. In the event you discover any evidence of questionable content or behavior, please communicate that to us immediately along with an action plan for addressing the problem. Thank you for your help in maintaining the quality of our products.


See: http://bogusconferences.blogspot.com/2009/05/bogus-conferences-ieee-confess.html

10 comments:

Johari said...

YES! many "IEEE" Conferences are absolutely garbage

Anonymous said...

Garbage conference also: IARIA, Petre Dini Conferences, Nagib Callaos Conferences, IEEE Sensor Networks Conferences, IEEE Computational Complexity Conference
Try to find more Bogus IEEE Conferences via google!

Anonymous said...

http://www.cg.tuwien.ac.at/~wp/videa-paper.html

WARNING: Beware of Wessex Institute of Technology !
Werner Purgathofer, Eduard Groeller, Martin Feda,
TU Wien / Austria.

Abstract
This paper illustrates that there are conferences which will destroy confidence in scientific life if the community does not forbid them. The Wessex Institute of Technology (UK) [1] organizes a whole series of regular conferences on various topics [2]. Our experiences are only with one of these, "VIDEA", but one should probably also be careful with the others. It is an offense against honorable scientists to offer false publication possibilities under a scientifically serious disguise for high fees. Our conclusion is: VIDEA accepts EVERYTHING! And we conclude from that that a publication in the VIDEA proceedings is worth NOTHING AT ALL! And to organize such a conference is simply a fraud. Conferences like VIDEA are a morally dispisable scheme to allow people to buy themselves publications without having to undergo any type of reviewing. It simply increases the flow of worthless data and makes it more difficult for scientists to extract really useful information

See:
http://www.cg.tuwien.ac.at/~wp/videa-paper.html

PETRE DINI said...

In my opinion the International Journal of Computer Science is a fake journals and this is itsdubious website http://www.ijcsi.org
for publishing paper, where there is no contact information about the author, just says UK, london. They want you to transfer money in France. There reviewers list is madeup of people from agriculture, biology, physics etc reviewing for computer science.

Dawn Cooper said...

The IEEE is like Microsoft, an American Commercial Company.
After so many complaints, after the internet fire with the IARIA IEEE fake conference, the HIGHSCI (IEEE in essence) Fake conference, they continue granting the IEEE name to IARIA and HIGHSCI.
Also, the IEEE continues sponsoring the fake conference of Sensor Networks and the fake conference of Computational Intelligence.
In my opinion, the unreliability of IEEE is obvious and does not need any proof.

The IEEE must stop the collaboration with the "Shops" like IARIA, HIGHSCI etc...
For the commission of the 15 - 30%, IEEE will lose everything. IEEE will lose its good name (eventhough in the area of conferences the IEEE name is now very very very low!!!!)

Anonymous said...

See this: http://entertainment.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=08/12/23/2321242

"Check out the paper Towards the Simulation of E-commerce by Herbert Schlangemann, which is available in the IEEEXplor database (full article available only to IEEE members). This generated paper has been accepted with review by the 2008 International Conference on Computer Science and Software Engineering (CSSE). According to the organizers, 'CSSE is one of the important conferences sponsored by IEEE Computer Society, which serves as a forum for scientists and engineers in the latest development of artificial intelligence, grid computing, computer graphics, database technology, and software engineering.' Even better, fake author Herbert Schlangemann has been selected as session chair (PDF) for that conference. (The name Schlangemann was chosen based on the short film Der Schlangemann by Andreas Hansson and Björn Renberg.)"

Thunderstorms Create Lightning said...

I recommend to each of you to create a SCIgen bogus paper and to send it to IEEE Conferences.
There is a 90% probability to pass it

I worked as follows
I submitted to the big and ... "famous" IEEE Power Systems Conference
http://ewh.ieee.org/conf/pesgm10/

a junk paper with the title: "Thunderstorms Create Lightning"
Actually it was the text from
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/06/090601140934.htm
and they accepted it!

This was necessary for me to take my Master Degree. My Professors gave me my Master degree, but I will not go to present and I will not pay the fees.

So, they told that my "paper" will be excluded from the "Proceedings"
Please, forward this information to your folks

http://sites.google.com/site/journaloftelecommunications/ said...

They accept ANYTHING you send them!! Want proof, try to send them some scigen paper and wait and watch! Funny!!

Name of Account: Chandramah Appadoo
Bank Name: National Westminster Bank
IBAN: GB90NWBK60193932123191
Swift Code: NWBKGB2L
Sort Code: 60-19-39
Bank Address: Southall Branch, 69 The broadway, Southall, Middlessex, UB1 1LD,UK

Journal of Telecommunications (ISSN 2042-8839)
http://sites.google.com/site/journaloftelecommunications/

Members of Editorial Board

Dr. Francisco Barceló-Arroyo
Associate Professor
Department of Telematic Engineering
Universitat Politecnica de Catalunya (UPC)

Dr. Boris S. Verkhovsky
Professor
Department of Computer Science
New Jersey Institute of Technology

Dr. Jasvir Singh Kang
Dean
Faculty of Engineering & Technology

Professor
Department of Electronics Technology
Guru Nanak Dev University

Dr. Nirmalendu Bikas Sinha
Professor
Department of ECE and EIE
College of Engineering & Management
K.T.P.P Township

Dr. Farid Nait-Abdesselam
Associate Professor
Department of Computer Science - LIFL
University of Lille, France

Dr. Jaime Lloret Mauri
Associate Professor
Department of Communications
Polytechnic University of Valencia, Spain

Dr. Sattar B. Sadkhan
Professor
Deputy Dean of Computer Techniques College
University of Babylon - P.O.Box: Hilla-4: IRAQ
Chairman of IEEE IRAQ Section

Dr. Ali Abbas Ali
Professor
Department of Electrical & Electronic Engineering
University of AI-ISRA, JORDAN

Dr. Kasim Mousa Alwan AL-AUBIDY
Professor
Dean, Faculty of Engineering
Philadelphia University, JORDAN

Anonymous said...

Really world is suffering from fake dull but intelligent researchers.I,being in W.B,India seen P.hd fellows,Prof.s to simply copy pasting modifying images of IEEE papers and submitting to IEEE and getting selected.They even don't know the basics(shame on you guys).Shame,shame,shame.....

Anonymous said...

Really world is suffering from fake dull but intelligent researchers.I,being in W.B,India seen P.hd fellows,Prof.s to simply copy pasting modifying images of IEEE papers and submitting to IEEE and getting selected.They even don't know the basics(shame on you guys).Shame,shame,shame.....